The Grayscale Effect Returns: What Spot ETFs Have Meant for Grayscale

·

In recent weeks, a familiar phenomenon has re-emerged in the crypto markets — the so-called Grayscale Effect. After announcing the launch of the Grayscale MakerDAO Trust, the MKR token surged over 5% within an hour, breaking past $2,100 and posting a 14.7% gain over seven days. This wasn’t an isolated event.

Earlier in July, Grayscale introduced the Grayscale Decentralized AI Fund, targeting high-potential tokens like TAO, FIL, LPT, NEAR, and RNDR. The market responded swiftly: AI-related assets rallied, with most components gaining over 5% in short order. Around the same time, the Grayscale Bittensor Trust and Grayscale Sui Trust were unveiled — both TAO and SUI defied broader market volatility, with SUI breaking the $1 mark and climbing more than 65% in a week.

👉 Discover how major crypto moves are shaping institutional interest today.

This resurgence echoes Grayscale’s influential past — a time when its strategic moves could single-handedly shift market sentiment. But what has changed since then? And how has the approval of spot Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs reshaped Grayscale’s trajectory?

The Rise of the Grayscale Effect

Founded in 2013 by Barry Silbert, Grayscale began as a simple Bitcoin trust — the now-iconic GBTC. By 2015, it was trading over-the-counter (OTC), offering institutional investors one of the first regulated gateways into crypto exposure. With no redemption mechanism, GBTC became a one-way valve: Bitcoin flowed in, but rarely out.

This structural feature fueled what became known as the Grayscale Effect. As Grayscale accumulated BTC — at times absorbing up to 33% of Bitcoin’s 100-day supply — scarcity dynamics tightened. The premium on GBTC shares soared, often exceeding 20%, driven by strong demand from institutions and hedge funds unable to directly hold digital assets due to compliance constraints.

The effect extended beyond Bitcoin. Each time Grayscale announced a new trust — whether for Ethereum, Solana, or Chainlink — the underlying asset typically spiked. Traders watched filings closely, anticipating similar momentum.

The Mechanics of Market Influence

At its peak, GBTC wasn’t just an investment vehicle — it was a liquidity engine and speculative catalyst. Large players like Three Arrows Capital and BlockFi exploited the premium by purchasing BTC, converting it into GBTC shares via private placements, then selling those shares at a profit once unlocked.

This arbitrage loop worked — until it didn’t.

By early 2021, cracks began to show. As Bitcoin’s price stabilized and new regulatory clarity loomed, the GBTC premium evaporated and turned into a steep discount — at one point exceeding 40%. Without the premium incentive, the arbitrage model collapsed. Simultaneously, key players like Three Arrows Capital and BlockFi imploded, dragging down Genesis Trading (a DCG subsidiary) and threatening the entire Digital Currency Group (DCG) ecosystem.

For a time, Grayscale’s future hung in the balance.

Turning Point: The ETF Lawsuit

In October 2021, amid growing pressure from competitors like BlackRock and Fidelity, Grayscale filed to convert GBTC into a spot Bitcoin ETF. The SEC rejected the proposal in June 2022, citing concerns over market manipulation and investor protection.

Grayscale didn’t back down. It sued the SEC, arguing that the decision was “arbitrary and capricious” — especially since futures-based ETFs had already been approved. After months of legal battles, a U.S. appellate court ruled in Grayscale’s favor in August 2023, ordering the SEC to reconsider the application under fair review standards.

The impact was immediate:

👉 See how ETF approvals are transforming crypto investment strategies in 2025.

While Grayscale wasn’t the first to launch a spot ETF (that honor went to others in January 2024), its legal victory was a watershed moment for the entire industry.

Post-ETF Landscape: Growth Amid Competition

With GBTC officially transitioning to an ETF in January 2024, Grayscale entered a new era — one defined by both opportunity and intensified competition.

As of mid-2025:

Despite this shift, Grayscale remains a dominant force. It now offers 21 crypto trusts and 5 ETF products, managing approximately $21.35 billion in assets. While its traditional trusts charge management fees up to 2.5%, its newer ETFs range between 0.15% and 2.5%, reflecting competitive pressures.

Strategic Expansion Beyond Bitcoin

Recognizing the need to diversify, Grayscale has accelerated product innovation:

These moves signal a broader strategy: leverage brand recognition to capture emerging narratives — from DeFi to AI — while maintaining core dominance in BTC and ETH.

Core Keywords & Market Relevance

Key themes driving Grayscale’s renewed relevance include:

These terms reflect both historical significance and forward-looking trends shaping investor behavior in 2025.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the "Grayscale Effect"?

The Grayscale Effect refers to the market price surge observed in a cryptocurrency shortly after Grayscale announces a new investment trust for that asset. Historically linked to GBTC’s accumulation power and premium trading dynamics, it has reappeared with recent launches involving MKR, SUI, and AI-focused tokens.

Why did GBTC trade at a discount before becoming an ETF?

Due to the lack of a redemption mechanism, GBTC couldn’t align its market price with its net asset value (NAV). When investor sentiment weakened and outflows increased — especially post-FTX collapse — confidence eroded, leading to persistent discounts exceeding 40%.

How did Grayscale win its SEC lawsuit?

Grayscale argued that the SEC applied inconsistent standards by approving futures-based Bitcoin ETFs while rejecting spot versions without clear justification. A federal appeals court agreed, calling the denial “arbitrary,” and mandated a fair review process.

Is Grayscale still relevant after ETF competition?

Yes. Despite losing first-mover advantage to BlackRock and Fidelity, Grayscale retains strong brand equity, a diversified product suite, and first-to-market positioning in niche areas like decentralized AI and DeFi governance tokens.

Can other crypto trusts follow GBTC’s ETF path?

Potentially. Grayscale has filed applications to convert ETHE (Ethereum Trust) into a spot ETF. Regulatory precedent set by GBTC’s case strengthens future approvals — though each asset faces unique scrutiny.

Is Grayscale expanding outside the U.S.?

Yes. In April 2025, Grayscale confirmed discussions with European partners to launch localized fund offerings, adapting to regional regulations and investor preferences.

👉 Stay ahead of global crypto trends with real-time insights from leading platforms.

Conclusion: A Legacy Rebuilt

The spot ETF transition didn’t just save Grayscale — it redefined it. From surviving regulatory battles and market crises to reigniting investor interest through strategic innovation, Grayscale has proven resilient. While no longer the sole gateway for institutional capital, its influence endures through product leadership, legal precedent-setting wins, and renewed market confidence.

As decentralized AI, DeFi governance, and next-gen blockchains gain traction, Grayscale is well-positioned to once again shape narratives — proving that even in a crowded field, legacy expertise still matters.